In-depth review
Withings Body Comp Review (2027): The Premium Foot Only Sweet Spot
Full research review of the Withings Body Comp: listed metric breadth, heart outputs, app and subscription landscape, and the daily routine advantage.
Withings Body Comp Smart Scale
The middle Withings: broad listed metrics and health outputs in a foot only platform.
- Weight, full body composition, and heart rate among maker listed outputs, with further health outputs in app
- Metrics listed
- Foot platform electrodes
- Electrodes
- Withings app via Wi-Fi and Bluetooth per maker specification
- App and connectivity
Our verdict
Body Comp is where the premium foot only argument peaks: a broad maker listed metric set, heart rate among its outputs, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, automatic recognition, and an app with genuine long term trend craft, all with a routine of step on and step off. It lacks the Body Scan's segmental party trick and carries Withings pricing, with some app extras inside the maker's subscription offering to check at purchase. For the majority of committed trackers in this guide's audience, it is the balanced buy: everything they will use daily, nothing they must grip.
What we like
- Maker listed set combines full body composition with heart rate and additional in app health outputs
- Foot only platform keeps the morning routine to step on and step off
- Withings ecosystem supports long history and export options per maker documentation
What to watch out for
- Premium pricing against budget scales listing similar metric counts
- Some in app features sit inside the maker subscription offering; check current terms
Who it is for
Daily trackers wanting premium app quality and broad listed metrics without a handle routine or flagship pricing.
Listed metrics and the foot only boundary
The maker list spans weight, full body composition, and heart rate, with further health outputs presented in the app. Everything arrives through the foot platform path, which sets the design boundary: no segmental split, and readings weighted to the lower body route every scale in this format shares. Within that boundary the list is complete for trend purposes, and the app presents it without the clutter budget apps are criticized for.
The app is half the product
Withings presents multi year trends, weekly views, and export routes that reward long ownership. Owners upgrading from budget scales cite the app as the felt difference more than the hardware. The counterweight is the maker subscription layer for advanced features; core tracking is documented as available without it, but verify the current split before buying so year two holds no surprises.
Routine, recognition, and the glass top
Automatic recognition files most weigh ins correctly once profiles bed in, and the scale wakes on step without buttons. The glass surface is the maintenance note: bathroom dust and wet feet marks show, footing should be dry for safety, and a hard flat floor is required for consistent readings, as with every platform in this guide.
Body Comp versus Body Scan, settled
The price gap between these siblings buys the handle, segmental outputs, and the extra listed heart features of the flagship. Buyers who will grip daily and use regional trends should pay it without regret. Everyone else is funding a feature they will admire for a month, and this review's consistent advice is to let your honest routine, not the flagship's spec sheet, make the call.
Key specifications
- Metrics listed
- Weight, full body composition, and heart rate among maker listed outputs, with further health outputs in app
- Electrodes
- Foot platform electrodes
- App and connectivity
- Withings app via Wi-Fi and Bluetooth per maker specification
- Weight capacity
- 200 kg / 440 lb maker listed capacity
- Users
- Multi user automatic recognition per maker documentation
What owners report
Commonly praised
- Effortless daily routine is the praise that repeats
- App design and trend clarity lead owner comparisons
- Heart related outputs interest owners tracking overall trends
Common complaints
- Subscription prompts inside the app annoy hardware price payers
- Glass top needs regular cleaning in busy bathrooms
- Setup for multiple users takes careful first week attention
Recurring themes from owner reviews on retailers and forums, summarised by our editors. Updated October 2026.
Sources: Withings Body Comp product documentation, Amazon listing specifications
Also consider
WithingsWithings Body Scan Connected Health Station
The flagship station: foot platform plus a retractable handle for segmental readings and heart metrics.
- Metrics listed: Weight, segmental body composition, heart rate, and ECG among maker listed outputs in app
- Electrodes: Foot platform electrodes plus retractable handle electrodes per maker specification
Sources: Withings Body Scan product documentation, Amazon listing specifications
Check price on Amazonor add to your Amazon cartChoose Body Scan if segmental trends and the fullest listed output set justify the handle routine and flagship price to you. Read our Withings Body Scan Connected Health Station review
GarminGarmin Index S2 Smart Scale
Six maker listed metrics, Wi-Fi sync, and a natural home inside the Garmin Connect ecosystem.
- Metrics listed: 6 maker listed outputs: weight, BMI, body fat %, skeletal muscle mass, bone mass, body water %
- Electrodes: Foot platform electrodes
Sources: Garmin Index S2 product documentation, Amazon listing specifications
Check price on Amazonor add to your Amazon cartChoose the Index S2 if your training data lives in Garmin Connect; ecosystem fit beats the Body Comp's broader list for watch owners. Read our Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale review
Research-based assessment: manufacturer specifications and documentation, cross-checked against retailer listings and recurring themes in published owner feedback. We do not claim hands-on testing we have not performed, and we make no accuracy claim beyond maker stated specifications.
FAQ
Body Composition Scales questions, answered straight
Does Body Comp need the Withings subscription?
Core weighing, composition, and trend viewing are documented as app features without the subscription, while the maker offers a paid layer for advanced programs and insights. The exact split is a terms page detail that changes over time, so check it the week you buy.
Can Body Comp measure heart rate reliably every day?
Heart rate is a maker listed output taken during the weigh in while standing still. Treat it as a resting trend datapoint collected under consistent conditions, the same discipline as the composition readings, rather than a spot clinical measurement.
What floor does it need?
Hard, flat, and level: tile, stone, or wood. Carpet and bath mats distort platform readings on every model in this guide. If your bathroom is carpeted, weigh in a tiled area or on a hard board placed for the scale.